How to recognize shoddy in nightmare renovation?

When it came time to renovate her outdated kitchen, Jane was eager to hire a contractor to complete the project. She wanted to replace the cabinets, countertops, flooring, and appliances to give the space a modern makeover. After soliciting bids, she chose a contractor named Bill, whose price fell right in her budget. He came highly recommended by several neighbors for doing high-quality work.

However, Jane began noticing some red flags as the project got underway. The lumber Bill used for the new cabinets and trim work had large knots and splits in some areas. The “granite” countertop lacked the polish and intricate patterning of real stone. The tile backsplash had uneven grout lines and wasn’t perfectly flush with the walls. 

When Jane asked Bill about these issues, he insisted the materials were all excellent quality and that imperfections in the finishing work were normal. Still, Jane couldn’t shake the feeling that the work was shoddy and that she was getting ripped off.

Like Jane, many homeowners hire contractors to perform renovation or construction projects on their homes. Most contractors are ethical professionals who complete quality work at a fair price. However, some may cut corners in order to increase their own profits. This is why homeowners must educate themselves on signs of shoddy work and inferior materials. Paying attention to key details, incl. builder’s insurance, can help homeowners avoid becoming victims of unscrupulous contractors.

This article will equip homeowners with knowledge to recognize quality materials and proper installation practices in construction and renovation projects. We’ll provide tips on what to look for in common materials like lumber, flooring, hardware, and more. You’ll also learn warning signs of improper work like crooked tile layouts, uneven finishes, and code violations. 

Education and vigilance are a homeowner’s best defenses against remodel nightmares. contractor scams and shoddy work. Arm yourself with information – and inspect work regularly – if you undertake any major home project.

Picture of George Nicola
George Nicola

George is a seasoned interior designer and property marketing strategist with over 13 years of experience. He specializes in transforming properties into visually stunning spaces, helping clients recognize the potential and beauty in each property. With an impressive international client base of exciting projects throughout Europe and America.

Definition of Shoddy Work

Shoddy work refers to poor quality, improper, unskilled, or careless workmanship.

It is characterized by inferior materials, sloppy execution, disregard for standards, visible flaws, cutting corners, and an unprofessional approach.

Even licensed builders and contractors can do shoddy work. Signs include uneven finishes, code violations, lack of permits, safety issues, and work that fails to match plans or specifications.

Homeowners should be vigilant to avoid hiring contractors who engage in shoddy practices.

Document the remodeling to avoid remodel nightmares

  • Always take detailed photos or videos at every stage of the project – this provides a visual record in case any issues arise later.

  • Keep a daily log of workers on site, tasks completed, materials delivered, discrepancies noticed. This creates a helpful timeline.

  • File away all invoices, contract documents, change orders, and communications related to the project. Maintain thorough records.

  • Conduct walkthroughs with the contractor before/after each project phase to note progress and get sign-off.

  • Carefully inspect all work and materials upon completion. Document any unsatisfactory or missing items.

  • Don’t sign off or make final payment until all project records are in order to your satisfaction.

Evaluating Contractor Materials

Contractor abandoned project during renovation
Contractor abandoned project during renovation

When a contractor purchases materials for your project, they don’t always provide the highest quality options unless specified in the contract.

Contractors may supply budget-grade lumber, lower-end appliances, standard tiles, and inexpensive fixtures to keep their own costs down.

Here’s what to look for when inspecting materials from a consumer point of view and avoid fraud:

Ongoing renovation that need design brainstorm? We can help with that >

Lumber Grade

Quality lumber should be free of large knots, splits, warping, and checks. Common grades used for framing and trim include Select Structural, No. 2, and Premium.

The highest grade, Select Structural, has few if any, blemishes. Contractors may try to cut costs and not be compliant by using lower No. 3 or Economy grades. Examine both sides of the boards when possible. Red flags include excessive large knots, wane (bark) along edges, bowing, cupping, and twisting.

Flooring

With hardwood floors, beware of very thin boards less than 3/8″ thick. Thicker planks around 3/4″ will stand up better over time.

Inspect edges for straightness and look for gaps/spacing issues between boards. For laminate and vinyl, make sure the flooring meets or exceeds standards for AC rating and wear layer thickness. Request product specs before installation.

Tile

Ceramic and porcelain tiles should be free of chips, cracks, uneven thicknesses, and shade variations within boxes. Higher-rated tiles withstand more stress.

Glazed floor tiles should be PEI Class 4 or 5. Check the straightness of grout line spacing after installation.

Hardware

Examine hinges, pulls, drawer slides, and bath/kitchen fixtures closely.

Cheap hardware has plastic parts, weak casting, and may already show scratches out of the box.

Higher quality hardware has solid metal construction and smooth, durable finishes. Brand-name products offer more reliability.

Builder Markups

Don’t be surprised if your contractor’s invoice shows materials costs 25-35% higher than retail prices. This covers the contractor’s transportation costs, delivery fees, storage, and product wastage during installation.

Confirm with your contractor upfront what their markup will be so you aren’t blindsided later. Consider purchasing products like flooring and appliances yourself to avoid markups.

Scrutinizing materials takes time but gives you peace of mind about quality. Examine products upon delivery before signing any paperwork. Pay attention to details, ask questions, and address any concerns immediately to avoid setbacks later on. Your diligence ensures you get what you pay for.

Signs of Improper Construction Practices

Partially remodeled room with bare walls, ladder, paint supplies
Partially remodeled room with bare walls, ladder, paint supplies

Even when a contractor uses adequate materials for a project, the quality of the finished product also depends on proper installation practices. If the materials a good quality, but the sub-contractor has no experience, this can cause a shoddy work.

Here are some red flags to watch out for with tile, drywall, carpentry, and other project elements:

Tile Work Standard

Tile layouts on floors, walls, and backsplashes require care to deliver a clean, uniform appearance.

Signs of shoddy tile work include:

    • Crooked or uneven grout lines and tile spacing
    • Lippage – some tiles higher or lower than others
    • Gaps between tiles and adjacent surfaces
    • Loose tiles that rock or click when stepped on
    • Spacing issues where tiles meet cabinets or trim
    • Grouting issues like cracks or pitting

Tile cuts should be clean and straight. Joints and corners should form precise 90 degree angles. Tile surfaces should be smooth and consistent, free of grout haze.

Drywall Finishing

Proper drywall finishing requires 3-4 coats of joint compound.

Signs of poor finishing work:

    • Visible drywall seams after painting
    • Excess dirt and dried compound in corners
    • Popped nail heads protruding from walls
    • Cracks or ripples along seams
    • Rough sanding marks under paint
    • Drywall corners not straight or properly finished

Paint coverage should be smooth and uniform without shadows from imperfections. Nail heads should be recessed and filled properly to prevent popping.

Carpentry

Construction materials in a room that is being remodeled

Trim, cabinets, shelving, and other carpentry work should be level, plumb, and square.

Watch for:

    • Cabinet doors and drawers that don’t close properly
    • Countertops not level front-to-back or side-to-side
    • Floor transitions not flush with flooring surfaces
    • Gaps between cabinets and walls
    • Misaligned edges on miter joints
    • Uneven deck board spacing and overhangs
    • Loose trim and gaps at seams

All joints should fit tightly with no excess glue or fasteners. Stair railing balusters must be evenly spaced and guardrails properly secured. Sanding marks should not be visible through paint.

Unsafe and shoddy electrical work

Shoddy electrical work often requires close inspection and testing to detect, since on the surface outlets, lights and appliances may appear functional.

  1. Using undersized wiring that can overheat – For high power circuits, the contractor may install thinner 12 or 14 gauge wire instead of recommended 10 or 12 gauge. This is not up to code and can cause wires to overheat.
  2. Failing to caulk penetrations – When electrical boxes and conduit pass through exterior walls, any gaps around them should be fully caulked to prevent air and water intrusion. Lack of caulking is harder to notice but can lead to issues.
  3. Improper grounding – Systems may seem to work fine even if ground wires are hooked up incorrectly or missing altogether. This violates safety codes and the issues may not manifest right away.

Other examples could include overcrowding wires in boxes against code, stapling wires too tightly, or splicing together wires improperly inside walls where homeowners can’t view the connections.

Consequences of not caulking electrical boxes

Not caulking around electrical boxes and conduit passing through exterior walls can have several negative consequences:

  1. Water infiltration – If the openings surrounding electrical components are not properly sealed, water can enter the walls through these gaps and cause damage such as peeling paint and rotting drywall. Proper caulking prevents water intrusion.
  2. Air leakage – Unsealed openings also allow air to flow in and out of the home’s envelope. This can reduce energy efficiency and drive up heating and cooling costs as conditioned indoor air escapes. Caulking helps minimize air leakage.
  3. Compromised vapor barrier – Electrical conduit often passes through vapor barriers in walls and ceilings. If not sealed properly, these penetrations can degrade the vapor barrier’s effectiveness and lead to moisture accumulation issues within the assembly.
  4. Fire hazard – In firewalls and fire-rated ceiling/floor assemblies, any penetrations made for electrical must be firestopped with caulk or putty. This prevents flames and smoke from spreading betwee

Unsafe Insulation

If you have any concerns about potential asbestos, lead paint, or other hazardous materials in an older home, have a certified inspector test before beginning renovations.

Only hire a licensed abatement contractor to safely remove and dispose of any dangerous materials.

Detecting Water Damage Issues

Water leaks and flooding can cause severe damage to a home if not addressed quickly. Here are signs of water damage contractors may try to downplay or ignore:

Plumbing Leaks

    • Discolored water stains on walls or ceilings
    • Soft, spongy drywall or flooring
    • Peeling paint or warped surfaces
    • Moldy odors and moisture in air
    • Dripping from pipes, leaky fixtures

Flood Damage

    • Water lines on walls showing high water level
    • Swollen or delaminating wood floors and cabinets
    • Soaked insulation and drywall with darkened edges
    • Rust on metal fixtures and appliances
    • Settlement cracks from shifting foundation

Roof and Siding Damage

    • Stains or drips from ceiling areas
    • Gutters pulling away from fascia
    • Dark streaks on exterior stucco or siding
    • Attic showing water penetration

Signs like these indicate water intrusion that requires mitigation. The contractor should thoroughly dry affected areas, replace damaged materials, and repair the leakage source.

Unaddressed water damage leads to rot, mold growth, and potentially hazardous conditions. Don’t let a contractor gloss over or ignore these warning signs.

Building & Construction Codes

Contractors must adhere to state and local building codes for all projects, large and small. Violations include:

    • Improper railing or stair dimensions
    • Low headroom in openings and at landings
    • Fire blocks missing between floors and wall studs
    • Lack of support for joists and beams
    • Insufficient structural bracing
    • Electrical issues like exposed wires or overcrowded boxes

If you suspect code violations, consult your local building inspector. Never occupy a space until the inspector has approved the work.

Homeowner Paying for Materials

When starting a remodeling or construction project, you’ll need to pay close attention to the payment schedule for materials.

Many contractors request an upfront deposit or progress payments to cover their materials costs.

Follow these guidelines to avoid overpaying or covering for materials you never receive:

Upfront Deposits

It’s common for contractors to request 10-25% down when you sign a contract and in some instances even more. This covers their initial purchases like lumber, equipment rentals, and other startup costs.

Ensure your deposit aligns with the amount of early materials they need to order right away. Don’t provide an open-ended deposit without parameters.

Stick to the Payment Schedule

Breaking payments into progress installments lets you pay as work is completed. The schedule should outline specific payment amounts and project milestones. Pay attention to the materials-related details. For example:

    • 25% when drywall delivered onsite
    • 15% when cabinets delivered onsite
    • 10% when countertops fabricated

Don’t deviate from the schedule even if the contractor requests earlier payments. Pay only when materials show up or installation is imminent.

Don't Prepay for All Materials Upfront

Play Video about shoddy work on abandoned house renovation

Some contractors may ask to be paid for all materials at the start of a job. This transfers risk to the homeowner, who loses leverage if the job goes south.

It also blocks you from approving products before they are delivered. Never pay your full materials portion until materials are onsite and you’ve inspected them.

Hold Back Final Payment

Withhold at least 10-15% of the total project price until the end as leverage to address any issues. Only make the final payment when all work is complete and materials are properly installed. Never pay 100% upfront or at the halfway point.

Inspect Materials Before Paying

When materials arrive onsite, thoroughly inspect them before releasing related payments. Ensure all items were purchased before providing payment. Reject inferior quality products; don’t pay for materials you didn’t approve.

With a clear payment schedule and vigilance at each milestone, you can guard against overpaying or covering for undelivered goods.

Only make payments explicitly tied to materials after verifying their quantity and quality. Doing so ensures you get what you paid for from start to finish.

How Do You Know Your Home Needs a Makeover project? You can find out in Home Makeover Guide.

Material Ownership and Removal

To avoid disputes, it’s important to understand who owns materials at each stage of a construction or renovation project.

The contractor takes on risk by purchasing materials upfront before receiving payment. As a result, the contractor retains ownership and rights over uninstalled materials if payment issues arise.

Contractor Owns Materials Until Installation

Lumber, tiles, fixtures, and appliances delivered to your worksite still belong to the contractor until they are fully installed and paid for.

The contractor owns the materials and holds the right to remove them until you make the associated progress payment in the schedule.

If you fail to make a payment for delivered items, the contractor can legally take them back since you don’t obtain ownership until the materials are paid for.

Contractor Can Remove Materials if Not Paid

If you miss a materials payment, the contractor can retrieve undeposited items from the jobsite – even if they were already delivered. You lose all rights to those materials until paying for them per the contract.

For example, if you haven’t yet paid for cabinets, the contractor can remove them – even if already installed – due to nonpayment. This can incur additional costs if contractor needs to repair demolition damages.

Purchasing Your Own Materials

Some homeowners choose to purchase certain materials like flooring, appliances, or fixtures themselves. This avoids paying the contractor’s markup on these items.

If you buy materials directly, you retain ownership and rights from the time of purchase. Any surplus materials leftover after project completion remain your property to use or dispose of as desired.

There is no risk of the contractor attempting to claim extra materials that you paid for upfront.

When buying direct, just ensure the products meet the contractor’s specifications. Also discuss delivery logistics and who will unload/store materials onsite. Paying for items yourself can save money but requires more homeowner involvement.

Homeowner Can't Sell or Dispose of Extra Materials

Sometimes excess materials remain at the end of a project. Any surplus materials or overages paid for belong solely to the contractor.

As the homeowner, you cannot remove or sell the excess materials yourself. Doing so could constitute theft of contractor property.

Any Leftover Materials Remain Contractor's Property

Suppose excess tiles, lumber, or hardware remain onsite after project completion. As leftover materials were included in the project pricing, they remain the contractor’s legal property.

The contractor may offer to sell them to you at a discounted rate but is not obligated to do so.

Set Expectations Upfront

To prevent disputes, discuss material ownership and removal rights with your contractor from the outset.

Make sure you understand that the contractor retains full ownership of products unless and until you make the associated payments. Clear communication sets expectations and helps avoid misunderstandings.

Knowing the contractor owns all materials until paid for in full protects you from potentially unjustified removal of items. Make payments on time and verify materials to retain your ownership rights.

Past Due Materials

If the contractor fails to pay suppliers for project materials, you may receive bills or liens on your home even though you already paid the contractor.

This is an unfortunate but common scam. Carefully review statements and invoices, and report nonpayment to authorities.

Flood Damage

Water damage from floods requires immediate response. Contractors should use equipment like dehumidifiers, fans, and removable flooring to dry out areas quickly. Walls and insulation saturated by floodwaters likely require replacement.

I see shoddy work.
What to do?

Take a note of key characteristics of shoddy work / poor workmanship:

    • Inferior materials used instead of higher quality options
    • Improper installation practices that don’t follow codes or standards
    • Visible flaws in finished surfaces like cracks, uneven tiles, crooked walls
    • Rushed or sloppy work with messy results
    • Cutting corners instead of proper preparations and process
    • Lack of permits, licenses, insurance required for the work
    • Safety issues created by subpar work
    • Work doesn’t match the initial project plans or contract
    • Materials not installed according to manufacturer specifications
    • Overall unprofessional approach and poor craftsmanship
house renovation designer
house renovation designer

Ongoing renovation that need design brainstorm? We can help with that >

Completing a home renovation or construction project involves a lot of trust between homeowner and contractor.

While most contractors are reputable, some unfortunately engage in shoddy practices that result in inferior quality and overpayment by homeowners. As we’ve covered, protecting yourself requires knowledge, vigilance, and proactive steps.

To recap, be sure to thoroughly research and vet any potential contractors before hiring them. Check reviews and references to verify their reputation. Scrutinize any materials they supply to ensure acceptable quality grades and types. Pay strict attention to payment terms, and only pay for materials after inspection. Document any issues immediately, and enforce contract terms requiring repairs.

No contractor wants an unhappy customer, so diligence from the outset maximizes the chances your project goes smoothly. Maintain friendly but transparent communication, and inspect work regularly throughout the project timeframe. Don’t be afraid to speak up about problems or things that look amiss. Reputable contractors will remedy legitimate issues.

With some projects, consider purchasing major materials like flooring and appliances yourself. This gives you more control over quality and can avoid markups. Just coordinate closely with your contractor on specifications, delivery, and installation.

  1. Gaining knowledge around contractor scams empowers you to get what you pay for.
  2. Do your homework in choosing a contractor, and keep a watchful eye during your project build.
  3. Pay attention to details, and don’t hesitate to call out problems.
  4. Follow the recommendations covered here to maximize your satisfaction and peace of mind.